Jury Awards $115.75M to Families of Flight Crew Killed in Afghanistan

Cook County jury has returned a verdict in favor of the families of three of seven crew members who perished in the dramatic crash of a National Airlines 747 cargo airplane in Bagram, Afghanistan on April 29, 2013.

The crash itself was captured on a dash cam video that went viral over the internet shortly after the accident occurred.

The plaintiffs sued National Air Cargo, Inc., an affiliated company of National Airlines, which through the employees of its regional office in the Middle East, planned, loaded and restrained five Mine Resistant Armor Protected (MRAP) vehicles for transport on a Boeing 747-400 converted freighter from Camp Bastion, Afghanistan to Bagram and then on to Dubai World Airport for offloading onto a sea vessel.

(WARNING GRAPHIC CONTENT: Video shows what appears to be a plane that crashed shortly after takeoff from the Bagram Air Base in Afghanistan killing all 7 people aboard. Courtesy of CNN and YouTube)

The MRAPs were owned by the U.S. Marine Corps and were ultimately destined for Yermo, California under the terms of a multimodal contract between National Airlines and the U.S. Department of Defense.

National Airlines had assigned the performance of work under this multimodal contract to a joint venture between National Air Cargo, Inc. in Orchard Park, NY and National Air Cargo Middle East FZE in Dubai, UAE.

There were five MRAPs loaded on the accident airplane: two 12-ton M-ATVs and three 18 ton Cougars.

The evidence showed there were an insufficient number of restraints or tie down points to restrain these vehicles, and the most that could be safely transported on the plane was one M-ATV and no Cougars.

Mine Resistant Armor Protected (MRAP) (Image Credit- US Army)
Mine Resistant Armor Protected (MRAP) (Image Credit- US Army)

Plaintiffs introduced evidence that the straps used to restrain the cargo were in poor condition, with some past their expiration dates, and that an insufficient number of straps were used to restrain the vehicles.

National Air Cargo Middle East provided for use of 24 straps with the M-ATVs and 26 straps for the Cougars.  Boeing determined that a minimum of 60 straps were needed just for the smaller M-ATVs.

Upon takeoff from the intermediate stopover in Bagram, the restraining devices for one or more of the MRAPs failed, and the rear-most MRAP went through the aft bulkhead in the tail of the airplane, damaging flight control systems and hydraulics to the extent that the airplane became unrecoverable.

The airplane quickly pitched nose-up and entered an aerodynamic stall causing it to fall and hit the ground.

The jury awarded the estate of Captain Brad Hasler a total of $47.25 million in damages.

Donald Nolan, Principal/Owner at Nolan Law Group
Donald Nolan, Principal/Owner at Nolan Law Group

The estate of First Officer Jamie Brokaw was awarded $43 million, and the estate of Captain Jeremy Lipka, an off-duty pilot in the cockpit, was awarded $25.5 million.

Each of these awards included an amount of $5 million for the shock and fright each of the men experienced from the time of takeoff until the time of the airplane’s impact with the ground.

“The jury’s verdict sent a message that our society still values human life and safety over the pursuit of increased corporate profit,” said Donald Nolan, who along with Thomas Routh of Nolan Law Group represented the estates of Jamie Brokaw and Jeremy Lipka.

The estate of Brad Hasler was represented by David Katzman and Bruce Lampert of Katzman, Lampert & McClune in Troy, Michigan.

Trials in the cases for the remaining four crew members are expected to be set shortly.